MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV

Do you want to find out which car is the best, MG Comet EV or Tata Punch EV? 91Wheels brings you a detailed comparison between Comet EV and Punch EV. MG Comet EV Price starts at Rs.7.00 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Executive and Tata Punch EV Price starts at Rs.9.99 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Smart 5S Electric AT. MG Comet EV can generate 42 bhp power whereas Tata Punch EV can generate N/A power. In terms of range, Comet EV provides a range of 230 km/charge (base model), and Punch EV has a range of 265 km/charge (base model).

Comet EV vs Punch EV

Key Highlights	MG Comet EV	Tata Punch EV
Price	Rs.7.00 Lakh	Rs.9.99 Lakh
Engine Capacity	N/A	N/A
Power	42 bhp	N/A
Mileage/Range	230 km/charge	265 km/charge

MG Comet EV

Executive

Rs. 7.00 Lakh

Get Offer

Tata Punch EV

Smart 5S Electric AT

Rs. 9.99 Lakh

Get Offer

Tata Tiago EV

XE MR

Rs. 7.99 Lakh

Specifications Overview

Comet EV specifications	Punch EV specifications	Tiago EV specifications
Variant Name	Executive	Smart 5S Electric AT	XE MR
On Road Price	7.37 Lakh Price Breakup	10.48 Lakh Price Breakup	8.41 Lakh Price Breakup
Fuel Type	Electric	Electric	Electric
User Rating	4.0 99 Reviews	4.3 20 Reviews	4.2 114 Reviews
Boot Space (Litres)	350 Litres	366 Litres	240 Litres
Transmission Type	Automatic	Automatic	Automatic
Max Power (bhp @rpm)	42 bhp	-	-
Colors	Comet EV Colours	Punch EV Colours	Tiago EV Colours
Images	Comet EV Images	Punch EV Images	Tiago EV Images

Add your vehicle to our online garage

Free valuation of your vehicle
1Mn+ users joined our Community
10+ experts to give advice

Which vehicle do you own?

Select your vehicle

Add vehicle

Exterior

Comet EV Exterior	Punch EV Exterior	Tiago EV Exterior
Sunroof Type	No	-	-
Sunroof	No	No	No
Power Windows	Yes	Yes	No
Adjustable ORVMs	Yes	Yes	Yes
Turn Indicators on ORVMs	Yes	Yes	No
Rear Wiper	No	No	No
Rear Defogger	Yes	No	No
Bootlid Opener	Yes	Yes	Yes
Rain Sensing Wipers	No	No	No
Daytime Running Lights	Yes	Yes	No
LED headlight	Yes	Yes	No
Projector headlight	No	No	-
Automatic Headlamps	No	No	No
Follow Me Home Headlamps	Yes	No	No

Brakes, Suspension & Tyres

Comet EV Brakes, Suspension & Tyres	Punch EV Brakes, Suspension & Tyres	Tiago EV Brakes, Suspension & Tyres
Front Suspension	McPherson Strut	Independent MacPherson strut with coil spring	Independent lower wishbone Mcpherson dual path (Strut type)
Rear Suspension	Multi-Link Coil Suspension	Twist beam with dual path Strut	Rear twist beam with coil spring mounted on hydraulic shock absorbers
Front Brakes	Disc	Disc	Disc
Rear Brakes	Drum	Drum	Drum
Wheels	Steel	Steel	Steel
Spare Wheel	Steel	Steel	Steel
Front Tyre Size	145/70 R12	185/70 R15	175/65 R14
Rear Tyre Size	145/70 R12	185/70 R15	175/65 R14
Turning Radius	4.2 meters	4.9 meters	5.1 meters
Tyre Size Spare	145/70 R12	-	175/65 R14
Wheels Size	R12	R15	R14

Instrumentation

Comet EV Instrumentation	Punch EV Instrumentation	Tiago EV Instrumentation
Low Fuel Level Warning	No	Yes	Yes
Adjustable Cluster Brightness	No	No	Yes
Fuel level guage	Digital	Digital	Digital
Gear Indicator	-	No	Yes
Shift Indicator	No	No	-
Tachometer	Digital	Analogue	No
Speedometer	Digital	Digital	Digital
Odometer	Digital	Digital	Digital
Avg fuel economy display	No	Yes	Yes

Infotainment & Communication

Comet EV Infotainment & Communication	Punch EV Infotainment & Communication	Tiago EV Infotainment & Communication
Apple CarPlay	Yes	No	No
Android Auto	Yes	No	No
Voice Command	Yes	No	No
Infotainment Screen	No	Yes	No
Multifunction Display	Yes	No	No
Touchscreen Size	10.25 inches	-	7 inches
Bluetooth Compatibility	Yes	No	No
Integrated Music System	Yes	No	No
Speakers	2	No	No
AM/FM Radio	Yes	No	No
USB Compatibility	Yes	No	No
Wireless Charger	No	No	-

Warranty

Comet EV Warranty	Punch EV Warranty	Tiago EV Warranty
Basic Warranty	3 Years/100000 Kms	3 Years/125000 Kms	3 Years/125000 Kms

Engine & Transmission

Comet EV Engine & Transmission	Punch EV Engine & Transmission	Tiago EV Engine & Transmission
Fuel Type	Electric	Electric	Electric
Transmission Type	Automatic	Automatic	Automatic
Gears	-	1	1
Power	42 bhp	-	-
Torque	110Nm	114 Nm	110 Nm
Battery Capacity	17.3 kwh	25 kwh	19.2 kwh
Battery Type	-	Lithium Ion	Lithium Ion
Charging Time	7 Hrs	9.4 Hours	3.6 Hours
Fast Charging	No	-	-
Drivetrain	RWD	FWD	FWD
Range	230 km/charge	265 km/charge	221 km/charge
Top Speed	-	-	120 kmph
Turbocharger	No	No	-
Compression Ratio	Yes	Yes	Yes
Motor Power	17.3	80.46 bhp	45000 W

Comfort & Convenience

Comet EV Comfort & Convenience	Punch EV Comfort & Convenience	Tiago EV Comfort & Convenience
Ventilated Seats	No	No	No
AC	Yes	Yes	Yes
Rear AC Vents	Yes	-	-
Automatic climate control	No	Yes	Yes
Heater	Yes	Yes	Yes
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors	Yes	No	No
Cruise Control	No	No	No
Start / Stop Button	Yes	No	No
Power Steering	Yes	Yes	Yes
Adjustable steering	Yes	Yes	Yes
Multifunction Steering Wheel	Yes	Yes	No
Leather streering wheels	Yes	No	No
Drive Modes	3	2	2
Keyless Entry	Yes	No	No
Electronic Parking Brake	Yes	No	-

Safety

Comet EV Safety	Punch EV Safety	Tiago EV Safety
NCAP Rating	-	Not Tested	4 Star (Global NCAP)
Airbags	2	6	2
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount)	Yes	Yes	Yes
Overspeed Warning	1 beep over 80kmph	1 beep over 80kmph& Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph& Continuous beeps over 120kmph
ABS (Anti-lock Braking System)	Yes	Yes	Yes
EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution)	Yes	Yes	Yes
EBA (Electronic Brake Assist)	No	Yes	No
ESP (Electronic Stability Program)	Yes	Yes	No
ASR / Traction Control	No	No	No
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System	Yes	Yes	Yes
Lane Departure Warning	No	No	-
Emergency Brake Light Flashing	No	No	-
Seat Belt Warning	Yes	Yes	Yes
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt	Yes	No	No
Rear Middle Head Rest	No	No	-

Dimensions & Capacity

Comet EV Dimensions & Capacity	Punch EV Dimensions & Capacity	Tiago EV Dimensions & Capacity
Length	2974 mm	3857 mm	3769 mm
Width	1505 mm	1742 mm	1677 mm
Height	1640 mm	1633 mm	1536 mm
Wheelbase	2010 mm	2445 mm	2400 mm
Ground Clearance	165 mm	190 mm	166 mm
No. of Seats	4	5	5
No. of Doors	3	5	5
Boot Space	350 Litres	366 Litres	240 Litres
Kerb Weight	-	-	1235 kg
Body Type	hatchback	SUV	Hatchback

Pros & Cons

Comet EV Pros & Cons	Punch EV Pros & Cons	Tiago EV Pros & Cons
Pros	Its one of the most affordable EV in the Indian market It provides a satisfactory real-world range of approximately 200 km, with the capability to easily cover 150 km Small dimensions makes it easily maneuverable in city traffic and tight parking The interior space is well managed with flat front area and plenty of utility spaces The Comet comes with a light steering and a small turning radius It comes with a decent number of features such as LED lighting, touchscreen infotainment, keyless entry, rear parking camera, folding rear seat among other The interior fit and finish looks premium like other MG cars Full with tech features such as wireless connectivity for Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, no button vehicle start system, digital key, iSmart features etc. A lot of customization options from the OEM		It provides a claimed range of 315 km but in real life, it would return about 200-250 km easily The 4-star GLOBAL NCAP crash test rating provides great confidence and build quality. The performance from the motor is decent and provides ample power and torque The boot space is large enough to store your luggage. The interior space of the cabin is great with good features on offer.
Cons	Due to its compact dimensions and limited interior space, it is not suitable as a primary car The unconventional design may not appeal to everyone's taste Primarily designed for city use, it has a restricted range and is not ideal for extended highway journeys Strictly a 4-seater car Lacks DC or fast charging support, resulting in an approximate charging time of 7 hours With a modest 41 bhp power output, the driving experience may not be particularly fun to drive The two-door design makes accessing the second row a bit challenging No available boot space when the rear seat is in use Notable omissions in features, including a rear wiper and washer, seat height adjustment, and spare wheel		The cabin quality has high scopes of improvement. Some panel gaps in the cabin are evident In EV, range anxiety is a great issue.

Detailed Comparison of MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV

Safety

Comet EV comes loaded with ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), Tyre Pressure Monitoring System, Seat Belt Warning, Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt, Hill Assist, Reverse Camera, Central Locking, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Fog Lights, Door Ajar Warning, Auto-Dimming Rear-View Mirror. Punch EV has ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), EBA (Electronic Brake Assist), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), Tyre Pressure Monitoring System, Seat Belt Warning, Hill Assist, Engine Immobiliser, Central Locking, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Door Ajar Warning.

Body

Comet EV has doors and seats. It is an with 350 Litres boot space, fuel tank capacityand a ground clearance of 165 mm. It is 1505 mm wide, 1640 mm high and 2974 mm long. It has kerb weight and 2010 mm wheel base. Alternativelly, Punch EV is an with doors and seats 366 Litres boot space, 190 mm ground clearance.It has 1633 mm height, 3857 mm length, 1742 mm width, .

Transmission

MG Comet EV comes with RWD and Automatic transmission. And Punch EV comes with FWD and 1 Automatic transmission.

MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Comet EV vs Tiago EV
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Citroen
eC3
₹ 12.76 - ₹ 13.56 Lakh*
Comet EV vs eC3
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Tata
Tigor EV
₹ 12.49 - ₹ 13.75 Lakh*
Comet EV vs Tigor EV
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Maruti Suzuki
Swift
₹ 6.49 - ₹ 9.59 Lakh*
Comet EV vs Swift
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Toyota
Glanza
₹ 6.86 - ₹ 10.00 Lakh*
Comet EV vs Glanza
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Maruti Suzuki
Baleno
₹ 6.66 - ₹ 9.83 Lakh*
Comet EV vs Baleno
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Citroen
C3
₹ 6.16 - ₹ 10.27 Lakh*
Comet EV vs C3

Punch EV Similar Car Comparisons

Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Tiago EV
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Citroen
eC3
₹ 12.76 - ₹ 13.56 Lakh*
Punch EV vs eC3
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Tata
Tigor EV
₹ 12.49 - ₹ 13.75 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Tigor EV
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Maruti Suzuki
Swift
₹ 6.49 - ₹ 9.59 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Swift
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Tata
Punch
₹ 6.13 - ₹ 10.15 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Punch
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
MG
Windsor EV
₹ 14.00 - ₹ 16.00 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Windsor EV
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Mahindra
Bolero Neo Plus
₹ 11.39 - ₹ 12.49 Lakh*
Punch EV vs Bolero Neo Plus

Tiago EV Similar Car Comparisons

Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Tata
Punch EV
₹ 9.99 - ₹ 14.44 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Punch EV
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
MG
Comet EV
₹ 7.00 - ₹ 9.84 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Comet EV
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Tiago EV
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Citroen
eC3
₹ 12.76 - ₹ 13.56 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs eC3
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Tata
Tigor EV
₹ 12.49 - ₹ 13.75 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Tigor EV
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Maruti Suzuki
Swift
₹ 6.49 - ₹ 9.59 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Swift
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
Tata
Punch
₹ 6.13 - ₹ 10.15 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Punch
Tata
Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 - ₹ 11.14 Lakh*
MG
Windsor EV
₹ 14.00 - ₹ 16.00 Lakh*
Tiago EV vs Windsor EV

MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV and Tata Tiago EV Owner Reviews

Comet EV Review
Punch EV Review
Tiago EV Review

- N
  NIRMALA
  6 Month ago
  5.0
  Good, very comfortable, easy to drive, very safe, compact for parking, and fuel-saving purposes are also good. Nicely designed overall good and happy to say this with
  Read more
  Likes (1)
  Reply
- BS
  Bibhudutta Swain
  7 Month ago
  5.0
  It's an excellent car for city driving. I hope everyone enjoys the benefits of the MG EV car and the driving experience of this small car. The looks are also very nice.
  Read more
  Likes (8)
  Reply
- Yl
  Yogesh lohar
  9 Month ago
  5.0
  All over, it is very comfortable in small car but one point is that a fast charger is not available This is drop point Other wise, a good vehicle as compared to a Tata vehicle is well done
  Read more
  Likes (7)
  Reply
- Ps
  Piyush srivastava
  10 Month ago
  5.0
  Good design, value of money, good features, comfortable, good space, good looking, nice colours and design, safety features, large space, electric car one of the best.
  Read more
  Likes (8)
  Reply
- A
  Anonymous
  1 Year ago
  3.8
  this car have good 230 km per charge or charging speed and 7 hrs it take time to charge . not best but good performance
  Read more
  Likes (10)
  Reply

View All User Review For Comet EV

MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV FAQs

What is the on-road price of MG Comet EV?

The on-road price of MG Comet EV is Rs. 7.37 Lakh in New Delhi.

What is the on-road price of Tata Punch EV?

The on-road price of Tata Punch EV is Rs. 10.48 Lakh in New Delhi.

Home /
Compare Cars /
MG Comet EV Vs Tata Punch EV

MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV

Comet EV vs Punch EV

Specifications Overview

Add your vehicle to our online garage

Exterior

Brakes, Suspension & Tyres

Instrumentation

Infotainment & Communication

Warranty

Engine & Transmission

Comfort & Convenience

Safety

Dimensions & Capacity

Pros & Cons

Detailed Comparison of MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV

Safety

Body

Transmission

Comet EV Similar Car Comparisons

Punch EV Similar Car Comparisons

Tiago EV Similar Car Comparisons

MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV and Tata Tiago EV Owner Reviews

MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV FAQs