user

MG Astor vs Tata Punch EV

Do you want to find out which car is the best, MG Astor or Tata Punch EV? 91Wheels brings you a detailed comparison between Astor and Punch EV. MG Astor Price starts at Rs.9.98 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Sprint VTI - Tech 5 Speed MT and Tata Punch EV Price starts at Rs.9.99 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Smart 5S Electric AT. MG Astor is 4 cylinder, 1498 cc Engine can generate 108.49 bhp @ 6000 power whereas Tata Punch EV can generate N/A power. In terms of mileage, Astor provides a mileage of 15.43 kmpl (base model), and Punch EV has a range of 265 km/charge (base model).

Astor vs Punch EV

Key HighlightsMG AstorTata Punch EV
PriceRs.9.98 LakhRs.9.99 Lakh
Engine Capacity1498 ccN/A
Power108.49 bhp @ 6000N/A
Mileage/Range15.43 kmpl265 km/charge
Read more
MG Astor Sprint VTI - Tech 5 Speed MT car
Sprint VTI - Tech 5 Speed MT
Rs. 9.98 Lakh
Get Offer
Tata Punch EV Smart 5S Electric AT car
Smart 5S Electric AT
Rs. 9.99 Lakh
Get Offer

+

Add Car 3

Ad

Specifications Overview

Variant Name
On Road Price
11.16 Lakh
Price Breakup
10.48 Lakh
Price Breakup
Fuel Type
Petrol
Electric
User Rating
4.1
4.4
Boot Space (Litres)
488 Litres
366 Litres
Transmission Type
Manual
Automatic
Engine Displacement
1498 cc
-
Max Power (bhp @rpm)
108.49 bhp @ 6000
-
Colors
Images
Astor Images
Astor Images
Astor Images
Punch EV Images
Punch EV Images
Punch EV Images
Ad

Add your vehicle to our online garage

  • Free valuation of your vehicle
  • 1Mn+ users joined our Community
  • 10+ experts to give advice
add vehicle
Which vehicle do you own?
Select your vehicle
Add vehicle

Exterior

Sunroof Type
-
Sunroof
Power Windows
Front & Rear
Front Only
Adjustable ORVMs
Electrically Adjustable
Internally Adjustable
Turn Indicators on ORVMs
check
check
Rear Wiper
check
Rear Defogger
check
Bootlid Opener
Electric Tailgate Release
Electric Tailgate Release
Rain Sensing Wipers
Daytime Running Lights
LED
Not Sure
LED headlight
check
check
Projector headlight
Automatic Headlamps
Follow Me Home Headlamps
check

Brakes, Suspension & Tyres

Front Suspension
MacPherson Strut
Independent MacPherson strut with coil spring
Rear Suspension
Torsion Beam
Twist beam with dual path Strut
Front Brakes
Disc
Disc
Rear Brakes
Disc
Drum
Wheels
Steel Rims
Steel Rims
Spare Wheel
Steel
Steel
Front Tyre Size
215/55 R17
185/70 R15
Rear Tyre Size
215/55 R17
185/70 R15
Turning Radius
5.6 meters
4.9 meters
Tyre Size Spare
215/60 R16
-
Wheels Size
R17
R15

Instrumentation

Low Fuel Level Warning
check
check
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
check
Gear Indicator
check
Shift Indicator
Tachometer
Digital
Analogue
Speedometer
-
Digital
Avg fuel economy display
check
check

Infotainment & Communication

Apple CarPlay
check
Android Auto
check
Voice Command
check
Infotainment Screen
Yes + 10 inch
check
Multifunction Display
check
Touchscreen Size
10.1 Inch
-
Display Screen for Rear Passengers
-
Bluetooth Compatibility
check
Gesture Control
-
Integrated Music System
check
Speakers
4
AM/FM Radio
check
USB Compatibility
check
Wireless Charger

Warranty

Basic Warranty
-
3 Year or 125000 km

Engine & Transmission

Engine Capacity
1498 cc
-
Engine Type
VTi-TECH 1.5
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
No. of Cylinders
4
-
No. of valves per cylinder
4
-
Fuel Type
Petrol
Electric
Transmission Type
Manual
Automatic
Gears
5 Gears
1 Gears
Power
108.49 bhp @ 6000
-
Torque
144 Nm @ 4400 rpm
114 Nm
Battery Capacity
-
25 kwh
Battery Type
-
Lithium Ion
Charging Time
-
9.4 Hours
Drivetrain
FWD
Motor 60 kW and Torque 114 Nm
ARAI Certified Economy
15.43 kmpl
-
Range
-
265 km/charge

Comfort & Convenience

Ventilated Seats
-
AC
check
check
Rear AC Vents
Blower& Vents Behind Front Armrest
-
Automatic climate control
check
check
Heater
check
check
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors
Driver & Co-Driver
Cruise Control
Start / Stop Button
Power Steering
check
check
Adjustable steering
check
check
Multifunction Steering Wheel
check
check
Leather streering wheels
check
Drive Modes
-
2
Keyless Entry
check
Electronic Parking Brake

Safety

NCAP Rating
-
Not Tested
Airbags
2
6
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount)
check
check
Overspeed Warning
1 beep over 80kmph& Continuous beeps over 120kmph
1 beep over 80kmph& Continuous beeps over 120kmph
ABS (Anti-lock Braking System)
check
check
EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution)
check
check
EBA (Electronic Brake Assist)
check
check
ESP (Electronic Stability Program)
check
check
ASR / Traction Control
check
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System
check
iTPMS
Lane Departure Warning
Emergency Brake Light Flashing
check
Seat Belt Warning
check
check
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt
check
Rear Middle Head Rest
check

Dimensions & Capacity

Length
4323 mm
3857 mm
Width
1809 mm
1742 mm
Height
1650 mm
1633 mm
Wheelbase
2585 mm
2445 mm
Ground Clearance
-
190 mm
No. of Seats
5
5
No. of Doors
5
5
Fuel Tank Capacity
48 Litres
-
Engine Oil Capacity
5 Litres
-
Boot Space
488 Litres
366 Litres
Kerb Weight
1303 kg
-
Body Type
SUV
SUV

Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Positioned as one of the most technologically advanced SUVs in its segment, featuring an AI assistant
  • Boasts a premium interior with a choice of two color options: Ivory & Sangria
  • The 2024 update introduces new features, including wireless charging, wireless connectivity for Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, ventilated seats, auto-dimming IRVM, and more
  • Aggressively priced, with the top model available at Rs 17.89 lakh (ex-showroom) and equipped with Level 2 ADAS
  • Offers an extensive array of features, such as a 360-camera, powered seats, automatic climate control, a 10.1-inch touchscreen infotainment system, MG iSmart Suite, a panoramic sunroof, and more
  • The addition of new lower variants enhances the overall value-for-money proposition for Astor
  • Offer a good number of standard safety features such as all-4 disc brakes, ABS with EBD, ESP, hill-hold, traction control, rear fog lamp, ISOFIX child seat mount, all-5 3-point seatbelt, seatbelt reminder, and more
Cons
  • No diesel engine is available
  • The turbo petrol engine doesn't offer a manual transmission
  • Base variants have only 2 airbags, whereas many other SUVs in this category now provide 6 airbags
  • Although the Astor is longer, wider, and broader than other SUVs, its wheelbase isn't optimal, resulting in limited legroom at the rear
  • The Astor is most comfortable for 4 adults; accommodating 5 adults might be challenging
  • ADAS is available in the top-spec Savvy Pro variant only with the 1.4-litre turbo engine
Ad

Which Car Do You Like More ?

Detailed Comparison of MG Astor and Tata Punch EV

Safety

Astor comes loaded with ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), EBA (Electronic Brake Assist), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), ASR / Traction Control, Tyre Pressure Monitoring System, Emergency Brake Light Flashing, Seat Belt Warning, Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt, Rear Middle Head Rest, Hill Assist, Hill Descent Control, Engine Immobiliser, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Door Ajar Warning. Punch EV has ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), EBA (Electronic Brake Assist), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), Seat Belt Warning, Hill Assist, Engine Immobiliser, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Door Ajar Warning.

Body

Astor has doors and seats. It is an with 488 Litres boot space, 48 Litres fuel tank capacity. It is 1809 mm wide, 1650 mm high and 4323 mm long. It has 1303 kg kerb weight and 2585 mm wheel base. Alternativelly, Punch EV is an with doors and seats 366 Litres boot space, 190 mm ground clearance.It has 1633 mm height, 3857 mm length, 1742 mm width, .

Transmission

MG Astor comes with FWD and 5 Gears Manual transmission. And Punch EV comes with Motor 60 kW and Torque 114 Nm and 1 Gears Automatic transmission.

Read more

Astor Similar Car Comparisons

  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Honda Elevate
    Honda
    Elevate
    ₹ 11.69 - ₹ 16.43 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Maruti Jimny
    Maruti Suzuki
    Jimny
    ₹ 12.74 - ₹ 14.79 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Tata Curvv
    Tata
    Curvv
    ₹ 10.00 - ₹ 19.00 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Mahindra Thar
    Mahindra
    Thar
    ₹ 11.35 - ₹ 17.60 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Skoda Kushaq
    Skoda
    Kushaq
    ₹ 10.89 - ₹ 18.79 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Hyundai Venue N Line
    Hyundai
    Venue N Line
    ₹ 12.08 - ₹ 13.90 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Volkswagen Taigun
    Volkswagen
    Taigun
    ₹ 10.89 - ₹ 20.00 Lakh*
  • MG Astor
    MG
    Astor
    ₹ 9.98 - ₹ 18.08 Lakh*
    Mahindra Scorpio Classic
    Mahindra
    Scorpio Classic
    ₹ 13.62 - ₹ 17.42 Lakh*

Punch EV Similar Car Comparisons

MG Astor and Tata Punch EV Owner Reviews

  • Astor Review
  • Punch EV Review
    • H
      Harish
      7 Month ago
      4.7
      Good car but low mileage otherwise very good car in this segment, all very good, like dealing with staff and service staff behavior, costly parts but good quality.
      Read more
      Likes (8)
      Reply
    • M
      Mahendra
      10 Month ago
      4.4
      It is designed to provide a comfortable and premium experience for its occupants. It features a spacious cabin, with ample headroom and legroom for both the driver and passengers.
      Read more
      Likes (10)
      Reply
    • R
      Ramesh
      10 Month ago
      4.4
      It comes equipped with a 10.1-inch touchscreen infotainment system, which offers a wide range of features, including navigation, music streaming, and smartphone mirroring.
      Read more
      Likes (4)
      Reply
    • MS
      Mohd Shadab khan
      10 Month ago
      4.4
      It is equipped with a range of safety features, including six airbags, ABS with EBD, electronic stability control, and a rear parking sensor. The vehicle also comes with a 360-degree camera, which aids in parking and maneuvering in tight spaces.
      Read more
      Likes (3)
      Reply
    • SS
      Surender Singh
      10 Month ago
      4.4
      It is powered by a 1.5-liter turbocharged petrol engine that delivers a decent amount of power and torque. Its handling is praised for its stability and responsiveness, making it a fun car to drive, especially in city traffic. The ride quality is smooth, and the suspension system absorbs bumps and potholes effectively.
      Read more
      Likes (3)
      Reply
View All User Review For Astor
Ad
Ad

MG Astor and Tata Punch EV FAQs

What is the on-road price of MG Astor?
What is the on-road price of Tata Punch EV?